oligarchies-in-Canada
by Paul Romani (M.Ed.)
SHARE
  

Oligarchies in Canada: Why Traditional Education is Failing Our Children

by Paul Romani (M.Ed.)
SHARE  
  

Parents fear that their children are not being equipped with the skills necessary to thrive in an increasingly complex and competitive world. 📉

This concern grows when they realize the same traditional educational system that failed to prepare them is now failing their kids. 🏫

The inadequacies of Canada’s traditional education system are evident when we consider the ongoing rise of oligarchies in Canada, where power and wealth are concentrated in the hands of a few, further exacerbating inequality.

The Rise of Oligarchies in Canada

Oligarchies emerge when economic and political power is concentrated in the hands of a few corporations. This concentration of power is often facilitated by a lack of competition and innovation (oligopoly markets) —both of which are hindered by an inadequate education system. When education fails to foster a diverse and innovative workforce, it creates an environment where only the elite can thrive, exacerbating inequality.

The Rogers-Shaw Internet Monopoly

Consider Canada’s internet service market as a case in point. Until 2023, Canadians had only three major providers: Rogers, Telus, and Shaw. This lack of competition has led to some of the highest internet charges in the world.

However, the 2023 acquisition of Shaw by Rogers reduced this to two, creating a duopoly. Canadians now have just two companies to choose from, which will only increase the power these companies have to dictate whatever prices they want to charge for internet access.

Other Examples of Oligarchies in Canada

The internet market is just one example. Oligarchies in Canada pervade many other critical sectors:

1. TV News and Newspapers

Media concentration in Canada is significant, with a few large corporations controlling the majority of TV news and newspaper outlets. Companies like Bell Media and Rogers dominate the landscape, leading to a lack of diverse perspectives and voices.

This media oligarchy limits the flow of information and stifles journalistic integrity, and it makes it difficult for new media ventures to thrive.

Canada has the most concentrated media ownership of any liberal democracy in the world—more concentrated than America’s, or even Britain and its Murdoch empire. In 1999, our five largest newspaper chains accounted for 93 per cent of all daily circulation.

Tim Logan, The Tribune

2. Banking

The Canadian banking sector is dominated by the “Big Five” banks: RBC, TD, Scotiabank, BMO, and CIBC. This oligarchy results in limited competition, which can lead to higher fees and less favorable loan terms for consumers and businesses. The concentration of financial power among a few institutions also poses systemic risks to the economy.

3. Energy

Canada’s energy sector, particularly in oil and gas, is controlled by a few large companies like Suncor, Imperial Oil, and Canadian Natural Resources. Oligarchies in Canada and the concentration of power hamper the development of renewable energy sources and perpetuates reliance on fossil fuels, which has significant environmental and economic implications.

Oligarchies in Canada

4. Real Estate Development

The real estate market in major Canadian cities is heavily influenced by a few large developers. These oligarchies in Canada often purchase and hold large tracts of land, known as land banking. By controlling significant portions of developable land, they can restrict supply, driving up prices due to scarcity, making housing unaffordable for many Canadians. The lack of competition in this sector limits innovative housing solutions and contributes to the housing crisis.

5. Farming

The farming industry in Canada is dominated by a small number of large agribusinesses. Oligarchies in Canada keep prices high for consumers and makes it difficult for small farmers to compete. Oligarchies in Canada in the hands of a few large producers stifles innovation and sustainability in agriculture.

6. Supermarkets

The Canadian supermarket industry is dominated by a few major players like Loblaws, Sobeys, and Metro. This oligopoly limits competition, resulting in higher food prices (including ‘shrinkflation’) and less variety for consumers. The dominance of these chains also squeezes suppliers, often forcing them to accept lower prices for their goods. These oligarchies in Canada can harm smaller producers and farmers.

The Link Between Traditional Education and Oligarchies in Canada 🔗

Education is the cornerstone of a fair and equitable society. The rise of oligarchies in Canada is not just a consequence of economic and political maneuvering but also a reflection of a populace that either willfully permits this concentration of power or lacks the skills, knowledge, and mindset to prevent it. The foundation of this issue lies in the shortcomings of our traditional education system, has fallen short in preparing students for the realities of the modern world. By failing to cultivate essential competencies, our schools inadvertently contribute to a society where oligarchic structures can flourish unchallenged.

1. Lack of Critical Thinking Skills

Without a strong emphasis on critical thinking, students may not develop the ability to analyze and question the status quo, making them less likely to identify and challenge oligarchies in Canada in media, politics, and business. 🚸 Traditional education often prioritizes rote memorization over analytical thinking, limiting students’ ability to engage deeply with content and form independent, informed opinions.

Experts like the late Sir Ken Robinson, who was an internationally recognized leader in education reform, long argued that the education system is outdated and unable to meet the needs of the 21st century. He emphasized the importance of fostering creativity and divergent thinking—skills that are often neglected in traditional education settings.

2. Insufficient Civic Education

Insufficient civic education results in a populace that is unaware of their rights, the workings of their political system, and the importance of their participation. 🌐 This gap reduces citizens’ ability to advocate for democratic reforms and hold those in power accountable. A well-rounded civic education is crucial for empowering individuals to participate actively in their communities and governance structures. A report by the Brookings Institution stresses that civic education must evolve to engage students in meaningful ways, promoting a deep understanding of democratic principles and practices .

3. Inadequate Media Literacy

Without proper media literacy education, citizens may struggle to discern biased or manipulated information, making them more susceptible to propaganda from oligarch-controlled media outlets. 📺 This vulnerability hampers their ability to seek out diverse viewpoints and form balanced opinions, contributing to a less informed and more easily manipulated populace. According to the Media Literacy Coalition, enhancing media literacy is critical for developing critical consumers of information in an age where misinformation is rampant .

4. Limited Economic Understanding

A weak foundation in economics can prevent citizens from understanding the implications of monopolies and oligopolies on their daily lives and the broader economy. 💰 This lack of knowledge reduces their ability to support and advocate for competitive and fair market practices, perpetuating economic disparities and concentrated power. The OECD emphasizes that economic education is vital for creating informed citizens who can navigate and influence economic policies effectively .

5. Deficient Legal Knowledge

Poor education in law and ethics can leave citizens unaware of the legal mechanisms available to challenge unfair practices and hold powerful entities accountable. ⚖️ This deficiency results in a lack of grassroots legal action against oligarchic behaviors and a weaker system of checks and balances in society. Legal scholars, such as those from the American Bar Association, argue that legal literacy should be an integral part of education to empower citizens to utilize the law in their favor .

6. Weak Technological Proficiency

Inadequate training in technology can hinder citizens’ ability to engage with and leverage digital tools and platforms that can democratize information and mobilize collective action against concentrated power. 💻 A strong technological foundation is essential for navigating and influencing the digital landscape of modern society. A study by the Pew Research Center highlights the growing importance of digital literacy in empowering citizens to participate fully in the digital economy and civic life .

7. Insufficient Awareness of Social Justice

A lack of education on social justice issues can result in citizens being less empathetic and less motivated to support equitable policies and reforms that challenge systemic inequalities perpetuated by oligarchies in Canada. 🌍 Understanding social justice is key to fostering a more inclusive and fair society. neaToday advocates for incorporating social justice into curricula to develop a more compassionate and active citizenry .

8. Poor Understanding of Global Affairs

Limited knowledge of global issues and geopolitics can prevent citizens from seeing the broader implications of oligarchies in Canada and the ways in which international pressures and alliances can be used to counterbalance domestic power concentrations. 🌎 A global perspective is crucial for informed citizenship in an interconnected world. According to the Global Education Monitoring Report, global awareness is essential for addressing the challenges of globalization and promoting international cooperation .

9. Underdeveloped Leadership Skills

Without opportunities to develop leadership and organizational skills, citizens may feel less empowered to take initiative in community organizing, advocacy, and political activism. 👥 This gap leaves oligarchies in Canada unchallenged and perpetuates the concentration of power. Leadership experts like John Maxwell highlight the importance of nurturing leadership skills from a young age to build confident and capable leaders who can drive positive change .

10. Lack of Entrepreneurial Training

Poor education in entrepreneurship can limit citizens’ ability to create and sustain independent businesses that can compete with large corporations. 📈 This limitation reinforces economic oligarchies in Canada and reduces market competition, stifling innovation and economic diversity. The Kauffman Foundation emphasizes that entrepreneurial education is crucial for fostering a culture of innovation and economic resilience .

The Need for Educational Reform

To break the cycle of inequality and prevent the rise of oligarchies in Canada, the country must reform its education system. This involves shifting from a one-size-fits-all approach to a more personalized and student-centered model. 🌟

1. Emphasize Critical Thinking and Creativity

Educational reform should prioritize critical thinking and creativity over rote memorization. This can be achieved through project-based learning, where students work on real-world problems and develop solutions. Such an approach not only makes learning more engaging but also equips students with the skills needed to innovate and adapt.

2. Foster Entrepreneurial Mindsets

Schools should encourage entrepreneurial thinking by providing opportunities for students to start their own projects or businesses. This can help break the cycle of dependency on established corporations and foster a culture of innovation.

3. Incorporate Technology and Digital Literacy

In the digital age, technological literacy is crucial. Schools must integrate technology into the curriculum and teach students how to use it effectively and ethically. This includes understanding the implications of data privacy and cybersecurity, which are essential skills in today’s world.

4. Promote Lifelong Learning

Education should not end at graduation. Schools should instill a love for lifelong learning and provide students with the tools to continue their education independently. This is particularly important in a rapidly changing job market where continuous upskilling is necessary.

Conclusion

The failures of Canada’s traditional education system are contributing to the rise of oligarchies in Canada by failing to prepare students with the skills needed to compete and innovate in a modern economy. To address this issue, Canada must reform its education system to prioritize critical thinking, creativity, and adaptability. Only then can we hope to create a more equitable society where power and wealth are not concentrated in the hands of a few but are accessible to all. 🌍

By addressing the root causes of oligarchies in Canada, we can empower future generations to break free from the constraints of oligarchic structures and create a more just and innovative society. This change begins with education reform, ensuring that every child has the opportunity to thrive and contribute to a dynamic and competitive economy.

Understanding the benefits of alternative high schools and progressive education is crucial, but finding one in a market dominated by traditional high schools is challenging.

That’s where we come in.

Benefits You Can Expect

“An exceptional educational experience”

Jon Ayre

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

“Pear Tree students think deeply about the big issues of our day”

“Their project-based learning approach is implemented with an enormous amount of planning and thought, and it shows in the high quality of the children’s work.”

Kate Chase

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

“Pear Tree’s learning approach is practical and impactful”

“Pear Tree’s staff are wonderful, very smart and kind, and focused on each individual student’s needs.”

Zahra Hudani

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

How it Works

Step 1: Schedule your visit

Start your journey by scheduling an in-person tour or attend one of our introductory webinars. This step allows you to explore our unique educational approach and facilities, and see firsthand how our students thrive.

Step 2: Apply Now

Ready to take the next step? Submit your application through our website. Our admissions team will guide you through the process, including document submission and a family interview to ensure a good fit both for your child and the school community.

Step 3: Welcome to Pear Tree!

Once accepted, you’ll receive a comprehensive welcome package and personalized onboarding session to ease your transition into the school community. We partner with you to ensure your child’s success from day one.

Here’s What You’ll Get…

The Pear Tree Method

Integrates academic, social, emotional, physical, and ethical development, nurturing well-rounded individuals ready for today’s complex world.

Theme & Project-Based Learning

Interweaves subjects through captivating themes and hands-on projects, fostering a deeper understanding and practical application of knowledge.

Small Class Sizes

Ensures personalized attention with only 16 students per class, fostering deeper learning and tailored support.

Advanced Literacy and Math Approaches

Tailored to our themes, our approaches deepen understanding and encourage practical application of essential skills in literacy and mathematics.

Masters-Qualified Educators

All educators hold master’s degrees, providing high-quality, passionate, and expert teaching.

Innovative Use of Technology

Prepares students for the digital age with meaningful technology integration, enhancing learning and 21st-century skills.

Healthy Hot Lunch Program

Daily, chef-prepared nutritious meals, ensuring students enjoy high-quality, balanced diets.

Sustainability and Global Citizenship

Teaches sustainability and global citizenship, preparing students to be conscientious global citizens.

Daily Physical Education

Provides diverse daily physical activities essential for students’ health and integral to their overall educational experience.

Community and Family Engagement

Promotes a dynamic learning environment by fostering strong partnerships with families and the community.